Councillors have approved plans to replace 25 permanent residential caravans at the Old Sawmill in Gargrave with 12 new homes.
The scheme on Marton Road will also see the former sawmill building converted into two apartments.
As the site is in a flood risk area next to the River Aire, a final decision will be made by the secretary of state for housing.
Two previous applications were refused by the former Craven District Council due to flooding concerns.
The latest application, submitted by Rebecca Hall, was also recommended for refusal by officers due to their view that the site could have potential for flooding.
However, Gargrave councillor Simon Myers addressed Skipton and Ripon’s planning committee to say the Environment Agency had recently revised the flood risk map for the area, leading him to believe the site was safe.
He said residents and the local parish council were in favour of the scheme, which had “been on the books for far too long”.
The applicant submitted a flood risk assessment from consultants at AECOM which concluded most of the site is not at risk of flooding.
Cllr Myers said: “Anecdotately this site has never flooded. There are other sites in the village which the planning authority has approved which do flood. At the end of the day, it’s an underused unattractive residential site that would benefit from a very good scheme.”
Cllr Robert Heseltine (Conservative and Independents, Skipton East & South) said he was satisfied the land was safe from flooding, adding “nobody has seen any caravans floating down the River Aire”.
Cllr Andy Brown (Green Party, Aire Valley) said he also supported the scheme as it would improve the village’s appearance. He added: “There are people living there at the moment and without being rude to those residents it’s not the most pretty situation in the world. This improves it significantly.”
Committee chair Cllr Nathan Hull (Conservative, Washburn & Birstwith) said it would be “sensible” to approve the plans and give the final say to the secretary of state who will examine the potential for flooding in detail.
He added: “Saying the site has never flooded in the past is no guarantee that it won’t flood in the future, particularly with the state of the environment at the moment.”

MP’s Small Business Award winners crowned as local businesses “fight on”
Christmas timetable revealed for Skipton trains
Spanish airport operator acquires Leeds Bradford Airport in £270m deal
Amended Christmas Bus and Train services in Skipton and Craven area
Skipton RFC scores £500 kit sponsorship with local opticians
Jack and the Beanstalk panto to be performed in Skipton
Number of primary school children being expelled a 'shocking indictment on society'
Steeton Court Clinches Victory in Annual Christmas Cake Competition
Airedale NHS microbiology staff announce December strike
Patrolling street marshals return to Skipton for festive period
Glusburn Community Arts Centre to host Santa's Grotto and film screening
Skipton MP Welcomes New Law to Protect Livestock and Farmers
Route Revealed for Rudolph's Tractor Run this Sunday
Skipton charity refocuses its mission as demand for children’s mental health support surges
Airedale emergency department 'exceptionally busy' with flu cases rising
Skipton Brass Band Conductor shines on Channel 5’s All Creatures Great and Small
Local dads raise £11,892 to support Airedale Hospital and Community Charity
Yorkshire Water finally lifts five-month hosepipe ban
Don't blame wildlife for £11.7m Kex Gill overspend, say Green councillors
New school observatory opens to inspire next generation of astronomers


